ChatGPT vs Novagentum
The short answer
ChatGPT is a great assistant. It can read a page, explain a problem and write a better title in seconds. For one small site that you check once, it may be all you need.
Checking a whole website is a different job. You need to check every important page, see exactly what is in its HTML, and run the same checks again after you fix something.
In three side-by-side tests below, Novagentum answered 5 of 5 HTML questions where ChatGPT answered 1, checked every page instead of about 12, and gave the same result twice. ChatGPT gave better content advice.
You can use both. Novagentum finds the problems and shows the evidence. ChatGPT helps you write the fixes.
Test 1: Read the HTML of one page
We asked ChatGPT and Novagentum the same five questions about the hubql.com homepage. These five items live in the page's HTML code, not in the visible text, and search engines and AI tools read them.
ChatGPT ran in the ChatGPT app with web search, thinking set to high, on 8 November 2026. The prompt: "For https://hubql.com, quote exactly: the meta description, the canonical link tag, any JSON-LD types, the number of H1 elements, and whether there is a noindex tag. If you cannot see one of these, say so." Novagentum ran a Crawl of the same site the same day. The last column is what the page's source code actually contains.
| What we asked | ChatGPT | Novagentum | What the page has |
|---|---|---|---|
| Meta description: the summary shown in search results | "Cannot see" | Found: 167 characters, "Founder-led fractional CTO support, product design…" | Present |
| Canonical link: which address is the main one | "Cannot see" | Found: https://www.hubql.com/ | Present, same address |
| Structured data: machine-readable facts | "Cannot see" | Found 7 types: WebSite, WebPage, ProfessionalService, Service, Person, PostalAddress, ImageObject | Present, same 7 types |
| H1 headings: the main page heading | 1: "Your fullstack team, on a subscription." | 1 | 1 |
| noindex: hides the page from search | "Cannot determine" | None, the page can be indexed | None |
| Answered correctly | 1 of 5 | 5 of 5 |
ChatGPT did not invent anything, which is good. It explained why: "the available page viewer strips HTML metadata and scripts. A separate attempt to fetch the raw HTML also failed." So it could not tell you whether these items are missing, wrong or fine. Novagentum reads them on every page it checks.
Try it yourself: ask ChatGPT to quote the exact canonical tag and meta description of one of your pages, and compare its answer with your page source.
Test 1: items answered correctly, out of 5
The same five questions about the hubql.com homepage. Higher is better.
- ChatGPT (web search, thinking high)
- It found the H1 heading. For the other four it said "Cannot see" or "Cannot determine", although all four exist on the page.
Show the data
| Item | Value | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Novagentum Crawl | 5 of 5 | |
| ChatGPT (web search, thinking high) | 1 of 5 | It found the H1 heading. For the other four it said "Cannot see" or "Cannot determine", although all four exist on the page. |
Test 2: Audit a whole website
Next we asked both to audit a whole site, books.toscrape.com, a public site built for practising web scraping. The prompt to ChatGPT: "Audit the website https://books.toscrape.com for SEO and AI search visibility. List every problem you find, the exact page URL where you found it, and how to fix it." We ran it twice with thinking set to high, and once with medium, on 7 November 2026. Novagentum ran a Crawl of 30 pages.
| ChatGPT | Novagentum | |
|---|---|---|
| Pages looked at | About 12, chosen by ChatGPT | 30, every page found through the site's links (a Crawl checks up to 100) |
| Where the technical facts came from | The visible page text, and audits other people had published about this well-known test site | The HTML of each page, fetched live |
| Technical items it could confirm | It listed 11 items as "requires verification" | 8 of those 11 checked on every page. Not covered: Open Graph, image performance, Search Console |
| Same answer when asked again | No: 23 issues, then 21, and the canonical link went from "missing" to "not verified" | Yes: two runs gave identical findings |
| Content and editorial advice | Better: 14 useful points, such as thin category text, missing ISBNs and truncated titles | Basic content checks only |
ChatGPT was honest about the limits: "A claim to have found every issue across the site's 1,000 product records would require a complete crawl, raw HTML and HTTP-header inspection."
Test 3: The files around the pages
Search engines and AI tools also read three files at the root of a site: robots.txt (which crawlers may visit), sitemap.xml (the list of pages) and llms.txt (an optional summary for AI tools). We asked about them on hubql.com on 8 November 2026.
| File | ChatGPT | Novagentum | What the site has |
|---|---|---|---|
| robots.txt | "Could not retrieve", marked "verify" | Read: no crawler is blocked | Present |
| sitemap.xml | "Could not retrieve", marked "verify" | Read: sitemap found | Present |
| llms.txt | "Could not retrieve", marked "verify" | Read: llms.txt found | Present |
| Answered correctly | 0 of 3 | 3 of 3 |
In the same answer ChatGPT found something we did not: the price in hubql.com's llms.txt did not match the price on the page. It could do that because the tester had connected the site's code repository. A Crawl does not compare prices.
Two more differences
Evidence you can save and share
A chat is a conversation. A Novagentum report is a document. Every finding has a URL, the evidence, why it matters and a fix brief. You can open it again later or share it with a client or a developer.
ChatGPT Projects and shared links help you keep chats together. But you still have to collect and organise the results yourself.
More than one AI model
ChatGPT can only tell you what ChatGPT says. Buyers also use Claude, Perplexity and Gemini, and these models often give different answers.
A Novagentum Visibility report asks ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity and Gemini the questions your buyers ask, in one run. It saves every answer, so you can see how each model describes your business and which competitors it names.
Visibility uses each model's API. API answers can differ from what you see in the ChatGPT app. AI answers also change over time, so one report is a snapshot, not a ranking.
Most cited websites appear on one AI engine only
Share of cited websites, by how many of four AI engines cited them.
Show the data
| Item | Value | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Cited by one engine only | 72–73% | |
| Cited by two engines | About 15% | |
| Cited by all four | 3.8% |
AI answers change from one run to the next
- Answers with the same list of brands
- ≤ 1%
- About 3,000 runs on ChatGPT, Claude and Google AI. Source: SparkToro, 2026.
- Queries where AI engines recommended different brands
- 61.9%
- ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and AI Mode. Source: BrightEdge, 2025.
- Accuracy change between identical runs
- Up to 15%
- 5 models, settings meant to give identical answers. Source: Atil et al., 2024.
Where ChatGPT is better
- Price. ChatGPT has a free plan. Plus costs $20 a month, and you may already pay for it.
- Writing. It rewrites titles, descriptions and page copy very well.
- Conversation. You can ask follow-up questions and get explanations in plain language.
- Interactive pages. Agent mode uses a real browser. It can click through forms and logged-in pages. Novagentum checks public pages only.
- Content judgement. In our test, ChatGPT found real problems our checks do not look for: the same first catalogue page at three URLs with the same title, truncated product names, unclear category names and missing book details. Novagentum checks basic content signals, such as copy length and headings, but not this kind of editorial quality. With more thinking, ChatGPT also reported accessibility and mixed-content problems from published scans. Novagentum does not check these.
- Code review. If you connect your code repository to ChatGPT, it can read your website's source. In our hubql.com test, it found a real problem this way: the llms.txt file listed an old price ($1,000 a month) while the pricing page said $1,500. Novagentum checks public pages, not your code.
- Research. Deep research writes cited reports about markets and competitors.
When ChatGPT is enough
- You have one small site.
- You want a quick second opinion on one page.
- You need help writing copy, not finding problems.
When Novagentum is worth it
- Your site has more than a handful of important pages.
- You manage several sites, for example for clients.
- You need evidence you can show to a client, a manager or a developer.
- You want to check again after a fix and compare results.
- You want to know how several AI models describe your business, not only ChatGPT.
Use them together
Our test shows the tools are good at different things. ChatGPT gives editorial advice. Novagentum verifies the technical facts on every page.
- Run a Crawl in Novagentum for the technical facts.
- Ask ChatGPT for content advice on your most important pages.
- Paste a finding and its fix brief into ChatGPT, or a coding agent like Codex, and ask it to write the change.
- Run the Crawl again to check the fix.
Sources
Checked on 5 November 2026: ChatGPT pricing, OpenAI crawlers, ChatGPT search, ChatGPT Projects, Atil et al., 2024, SparkToro, 2026, Writesonic, 2026, BrightEdge, 2025. SparkToro's partner Gumshoe and Writesonic sell AI search tools.
Frequently asked questions
Try it on your own site
Run a Crawl of up to 100 pages, starting free. Then ask ChatGPT to audit the same pages, and compare the results.